Hydroelectric Plant Proposal Threatening Catskills' Ashokan Reservoir Withdrawn
Update April 13:
On April 12, Premium Energy Holdings withdrew its hydroelectric proposal for the Ashokan Reservoir after strong opposition and concern about the impact of the project. Our congratulations and thanks go out to everyone who helped to stand up against this threat to the Catskills.
However, our work is not finished. Premium Energy plans to look for other reservoirs in the New York City watershed for its energy project. This energy company and others will continue to look for viable sites within our region. The Trail Conference will remain vigilant and alert our community if any new proposals pose a threat to the trails and natural areas we protect. We will continue to stand up for open spaces and your safe, enjoyable connection to them.
The Trail Conference opposes a proposed hydroelectric facility that would irreversibly damage areas of the Catskill Forest Preserve. We need your help to stop this ill-conceived project.
Premium Energy Holdings of Southern California has proposed a pumped-storage hydroelectric facility within the boundaries of the Forever Wild lands of the Catskill Forest Preserve that would have negative impacts on the Ashokan Reservoir and surrounding area. This proposal directly threatens the experience of trail users in the Catskill Forest Preserve, the ecological sustainability of the Forest Preserve, trout breeding grounds, the quality of the New York City water supply, and so much more. The Trail Conference has submitted a formal request to be an intervenor to the proposed Ashokan hydro dams.
We are calling on the trail community to speak up against the proposed dam to protect this special land. The deadline to submit comments about the proposal is Monday, April 12.
The process of making your voice heard NOW is imperative and very simple. Heres's how to take action:
On Feb. 18, a notice in the Federal Register alerted communities in the Catskills near the Ashokan Reservoir to a preliminary application filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) by Premium Energy Holdings of Southern California for a large and poorly conceived “pumped storage” project. It would draw from the existing Ashokan Reservoir, plus a newly created dam and reservoir at one of three alternative sites near the Ashokan, for generating hydroelectric power. If you're looking for a deep dive on the proposal, check out this presentation by journalist Ginger Strand.
Who's Speaking Up?
The plan was submitted with no input from New York City’s Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP), New York State’s Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), or from local leaders and stakeholders. NYCDEP and NYSDEC, along with the following municipalities, have filed or are reported to be filing comments, along with motions for formal status as intervenors (what this means is described below):
- Town of Olive
- Town of Shandaken
- Town of Woodstock
- Town of Hunter
- Greene County
- Ulster County
- Coalition of Watershed Towns
- Mountaintop Supervisors & Mayors Coalition (Supporting the Town of Hunter's opposition)
A broad range of local nonprofit groups opposing the project are formally commenting and seeking status as intervenors:
- Adirondack Mountain Club
- Ashokan Center
- Ashokan-Pepacton Chapter, Trout Unlimited
- Catskill 3500 Club
- The Catskill Center
- Catskill Fly Fishing Center & Museum
- Catskill Mountain Chapter, Trout Unlimited
- Catskill Mountain Club
- Mountain Cloves Scenic Byway
- New York-New Jersey Trail Conference
- NYS Council, Trout Unlimited
- Sierra Club, Atlantic Chapter
- Woodstock Land Conservancy
What does it mean to intervene and who can do it? Among the ways that a person, organization, agency, or municipality can participate in reviewing–and objecting to–a proposal submitted to FERC, seeking status as an intervenor preserves the most rights, including the right to participate in legal actions brought in regard to a proposal. The process involves discerning whether and how one might be harmed by a proposed project and then submit a short Motion to Intervene to FERC. Individuals could be harmed, for example, if they own property that might be flooded by the proposed dams and reservoirs or if they recreate on lands that would be adversely affected by the construction or operation of the project. The Trail Conference has submitted a request for intervenor status.
How You Can Take Action
- Learn more about the proposed project..
- Write to the Federal Regulatory Energy Commission (FERC) by the April 12 deadline about why this proposed project is not good for the Catskills and how it could impact you. Submit concerns online at ferconline.ferc.gov/QuickComment.aspx and reference docket P-15056.
- Contact local representatives: Senator Schumer, Senator Gillibrand, and Congressman Delgado.
What should you mention in your comments to FERC and your representatives?
- Reference docket P-15056
- The Catskills are a State Preserve protected by the NY State Constitution.
- The proposed dam, reservoir, powerhouse, pipeline, and subsequent powerlines will significantly and permanently damage the viewshed and trail user experience from multiple hiking trails.
- The road closures in the proposed pumped storage project eliminate vital access points to popular hiking destinations and recreational resources. The elimination of these trailheads will force increased usage in other areas of the Forest Preserve and magnify the negative ecological impacts that we have observed over the past 12 months due to unprecedented visitation on these trails during the pandemic.
- The required powerline right of ways will cross different ecosystems and fragment habitat, lead to the clearing of sensitive vegetation and create pathways for the spread of invasive species. There is also the unnecessary risk of the introduction of invasive species into the Forest Preserve during the construction of these facilities, as cited in a Pennsylvania State University study of gas drilling platforms.
- The lands and waterways that support the native flora and fauna that are synonymous with the Forest Preserve would be irreversibly damaged and affected by the construction of new dams and reservoirs; the noise pollution from the operation of the facilities would additionally produce undesirable impacts on the trail user experience.
- This plan would increase turbidity and negatively impact NYC’s drinking water.
- It would cause a significant impact on the streams, affecting fishing, boating, and swimming.
- Rerouting Route 214 (a Scenic Byway) would be incredibly disruptive.
- The loss of tourist dollars and business revenue would directly hurt our communities.
- The plan could limit access to skiing/concerts at Hunter Mountain, Hunter, and Tannersville.